Best Local Pies for Your Thanksgiving Table
Buttery crusts, decadent fillings, and irresistible seasonal flavors are taking center stage at Austin’s bakeries this Thanksgiving. From petite pies perfect for sampling to full sized classics that can feed a crowd, the city is brimming with options. Here is your guide to the best local pies to bring to the table and make the holiday even sweeter.
Tiny Pies
Order for Pickup or Delivery | Daily | Multiple Locations (Burnet, South Lamar) | Austin, TX
Scratch-made mini and full-size pies (flavors like apple crumb, tart cherry, sweet Texas pecan)—a fan favorite among Austinites
Texan Cafe & Pie Shop
Order for Pickup or Delivery | Daily | Multiple Locations (Hutto, Taylor) | Austin, TX
Every pie is made from scratch with buttery crusts and classic southern flavors like pecan, coconut cream, and apple.
Abby Jane Bakeshop
Pre-order by Mid‑November | Dripping Springs, TX (~30 mi west)
Wholesome, Texas‑sourced pies—classic pumpkin, pecan, and inventive combos like chocolate‑maple‑pecan
Dai Due
Pickup Nov 26–27 | 2406 Manor Rd | Austin, TX
Choose from pie dough kits (with rendered‑lard crust) or ready‑made apple and buttermilk pies—plus unique butterscotch squash loaves
Pie Jacked
Pre-order by Nov 16 | 1105 S Mays St | Round Rock, TX (~20 mi north)
Gluten‑free options for classic pies and mini‑pie packs—ideal if you have dietary restrictions
Pie Bar
Call to Order Full-Size | 8900 S Congress Ave | Austin, TX
Customize your own 4″ pie or choose from full-size pies, mousses, cobblers, and cheesecakes
Upper Crust Bakery & Café
Order Anytime | 4508 Burnet Rd | Austin, TX
Offering 10″ deep-dish pies daily, including pecan and Dutch apple—great for feeding a crowd
Texas Pie Company
Dine-In or To-Go | 10:30 AM–6:30 PM Mon–Fri, Sat till 4 PM | 202 W Center St, | Kyle, TX
Classic, family‑recipe pies baked fresh daily—perfect for traditional holiday flavor
Sugar Mama’s Bakeshop
Order Online | 1905 S First St | Austin, TX
Seasonal mini and full-size pies—expect rotating flavors aligned with fall harvest
Bakery Lorraine & Chez Zee
Order with 48 hr Notice | Allandale (Chez Zee) & Central Locations (Bakery Lorraine)
Both offer classic pies like pumpkin‑pecan praline and eggnog—order early
Quack’s Bakery
Order Anytime | Multiple Locations (Hyde Park, South, Mueller) | Austin, TX
Traditional cherry, key lime, and chocolate cream pies by the slice or whole
No matter how you slice it, these local pies are the secret ingredient to a Thanksgiving everyone will remember.
Recent Posts
